Master’s in HR vs MBA in HR: Which is the Better Choice?

One of the most significant decisions you will face as an aspiring HR professional in the US is choosing between a master’s program and an MBA to further your career. Both these programs can help you land leadership roles. However, they differ in focus, career outcomes, and skills.

Master’s programs typically focus on talent management, organizational development, and labour relations. MBA programs, however, combine human resource expertise with management and business strategy.

Both of these programs can help you secure HR jobs, which are among the most prestigious and lucrative roles in the US. For example, if you work as an HR manager, you can earn anywhere between USD 68,000 and USD 100,000 a year. The average annual salary for this position is USD 89,000.

This blog will compare master’s in HR and MBA programs in terms of their effectiveness in securing the top jobs in the US. It will provide you with all the information you need to make the best career choice.

Master’s in HR vs. MBA in HR: Key Differences Explained

Before deciding between an MBA and a master’s in HR, you must understand how they differ from each other.

1. Program Focus
2. Curriculum Depth
3. Ideal Candidates 
4. Career Outcomes
5. Salary Potential
6. Skill Development
7. Time and Investment
8. Global vs. Specialized Research

1. Program Focus

An MBA in HR offers you comprehensive business education while specializing in HR. On the other hand, a master’s in HR provides you with specialized and deep knowledge in every aspect of HR management.

An MBA in HR aims to produce versatile managers who can transition into general management positions or lead in various business areas, such as HR. But a master’s in HR prepares you to succeed only in specialized careers in the HR domain.

2. Curriculum Depth 

An MBA in HR provides a general business education that encompasses areas such as finance, operations, accounting, and strategy, with a focus on HR as the area of specialization. On the contrary, the curriculum of a master’s program in HR focuses solely on critical topics related to HR.

This includes the likes of the following:

• Talent Management
• Recruitment
• Compensation
• Labor Relations

Also Read: How to Become a Successful HR Professional

3. Ideal Candidates 

The following table compares the ideal candidates for an MBA in HR and a master’s in HR:

MBA in HR	Master’s in HR
Students who want to go into strategic or executive leadership positions Students who are interested in broad business education while specializing in HR Students who want to be able to work in different careers after graduation	Students who are clearly committed to a career specifically in HR Students who want to develop deep expertise in people management Students who are interested in the social aspects of HR

4. Career Outcomes  

• Graduating with an MBA in HR opens doors to a diverse array of leadership and business roles beyond HR. This includes executive and general management positions as well.
• On the contrary, with a master’s in HR, you will be limited to working only in HR-specific roles such as HR manager, talent acquisition specialist, and HR consultant.
• An MBA in HR helps you develop a strategic mindset to align HR initiatives with the overall goals of the business. This is crucial if you aspire to work in executive-level positions.
• However, with a master’s in HR, you develop specialized knowledge and skills to manage and understand people in an organization a lot more effectively than what you would learn in a generalized program like an MBA.

5. Salary Potential

An MBA in HR typically leads to higher salaries because the program has a broader business perspective. It helps you qualify for executive positions, such as CHRO and Director of Human Resources.

The salary ceiling of a master’s in HR might be lower compared to an MBA in HR in the long run, even though it may help you land advanced HR jobs. This is because these programs lack the broad business context that MBAs offer.

6. Skill Development

An MBA in HR helps you develop skills in general areas of business, such as finance, marketing, accounting, and strategy, in addition to HR. On the other hand, a master’s in HR focuses primarily on developing specialized skills and knowledge for managing human resources and people.

7. Time and Investment

Both these programs take two years to complete. However, some specialized programs can be completed in a year or less.

The initial investment in an MBA in HR is higher than a master’s in HR, but in the long run, the former can help you earn higher salaries.

8. Global vs. Specialized Research

An MBA in HR has a broader career reach and prepares you for roles in strategic leadership and general management. A master’s in HR provides you with a more specialized and deeper reach in the domain of HR.

Also Read: HRM Job Opportunities in the U.S. with a Master’s Degree

How to decide between a Master’s in HR and an MBA in HR?

You should consider a master’s in HR if you want to focus only on HR, are interested in the core functions of an HR professional, and/or are looking for focused education.

However, you should consider an MBA in HR when you are shooting for senior leadership positions, want to combine HR expertise, want to keep your career options open, and/or are an experienced professional.

Apart from these, you must be aware of the pros and cons of an MBA in HR.

Return on Investment: Tuition, Time-to-Payback & Salary Trajectories 

When you compare a master’s in HR and an MBA, the tuition fee for a master’s in HR is lower than that of an MBA because the latter has a broader scope and covers various business topics as well.

You can get a faster payback in a master’s in HR compared to that of an MBA. This is especially true when you land a specialized HR role that leads to quicker increases in compensation.

The earning potential is greater in an MBA program as it leads to broader career paths with the potential to attain higher executive-level positions.

Employer Preferences & Hiring Signals: What HR Recruiters Actually Look For

This is an important area of comparison between a master’s in HR and an MBA. In the US, HR recruiters typically look at the following factors for recruitment:

• Experience and Skills
• Communication
• Collaboration and Teamwork
• Adaptability
• Accountability and Integrity
• Enthusiasm and Passion
• Initiative and Ambition

These can be effective hiring signals for you in these interviews:

• Company Research
• Probing Questions
• Honesty
• Presentation
• Self-Awareness

Also Read: Is a Master’s in Human Resource Management (HRM) Worth It?

Real-World Case Studies 

X, who graduated with a master’s in HR from one of the leading universities in the US, was able to land a job at a Fortune 500 company. Their expertise in organizational psychology and labor laws enabled them to create effective employee engagement programs. This improvement increased the organization’s retention rate by 20% over two years.

Y, who graduated with an MBA in HR from a similarly prestigious university, gained the position of HR director at a top tech firm. Their strong HR knowledge and business acumen helped them successfully integrate corporate strategies with HR goals.

This made the company’s workforce more productive and drove talent acquisition programs, enabling rapid global expansion.

How Edgewood Helps You Advance Your HR Career?

The Master of Science in Human Resource Management and Development Online of Edgewood University teaches you strategic HR practices, cultivates leadership skills, and provides you with an industry-aligned curriculum.

The program, available through Edgewood, helps you excel in leadership roles by developing your business decision-making and strategic thinking skills. For this, it offers you case studies, practical applications, and projects.

It also aligns with SHRM standards to ensure that you remain relevant in the job market. This has a highly positive impact on your career.

Q: Is a master’s in HR in the US really worth it for career growth?
Ans: Yes, typically, a master’s degree in HR in the US can help advance your career to senior roles and higher salaries.

Q: What is the average salary for HRM graduates in the US?
Ans: This depends on factors such as your job role and experience in that role. For example, HR managers earn an average annual salary of USD 89,000.

Q: Can you move into HR leadership without prior HR experience in the US?
Ans: Yes, in the US, you can transition into HR leadership roles even if you don’t have previous HR experience.

Q: Are online HRM programs respected by employers in the US?
Ans: Yes, employers in the US typically respect online HRM programs, especially those from reputable and accredited institutions.

Q: What industries are hiring HR leaders the most in the US?
Ans: These industries hire the maximum HR leaders in the US:

• Technology
• Healthcare
• Professional Services
• Logistics and E-Commerce
• Construction
• Financial Services and Banking