Elementary vs Middle School Teaching: Pros and Cons

If you are interested in building a career in the education sector, you need to decide the age group you want to target. It can be challenging to determine whether you want a career in teaching Middle school or Elementary school. Both Elementary and Middle school have their own sets of challenges and rewards, which make them unique in their own sense.

Are you interested and comfortable working with small children in an Elementary school? Or, are you more inclined toward working with independent kids in Middle school? The answer to these questions can provide some clarity.

This blog will guide you about teaching Middle and Elementary schools, the advantages and disadvantages of both, and various Education programs offered by Edgewood University that can shape your career.

Take your skills to the next level — Explore Doctor of Education in K-12 Educational Leadership Online

Teaching Middle School vs Elementary: Which Path Suits You Best?

There is no clear answer to the question: ’Which is easier: Teaching Middle school or Elementary?’ It depends on your expectations, preferences, and ability to handle the challenges. Let’s look at some pointers that can make this decision easy.

Factor	Elementary School	Middle School
Age group	5-11 years (K-5/K-6)	11-14 years (Grade 6-8)
Subjects	Usually all subjects	Specialization in a specific subject
Classroom style	Mainly in a single class every day	Subject-based classes daily, multiple groups
Teaching style	Caring and supportive	Encouraging and mentoring
Certification	Elementary education	Subject-specific Middle grade
Challenges	Short attention span and needs nurturing	Peer pressure and emotional challenges
Fit for	Patient and nurturing person	Flexible and passionate (subject) person

Student Age and Developmental Needs

Elementary school students are in the 5-11-year age group, during which they are in the early phases of emotional development.

Elementary school educators should:

Teach basic skills such as reading or writing.
Regulate emotions.
Build self-esteem.

Middle school students are in the age group of 11-14 years when they are transitioning physically and emotionally.

Middle school educators should:

Manage puberty-related challenges.
Adapt to new people and surroundings.
Teach cognitive skills such as time management or organizational development.

Subject Focus and Teaching Style

Elementary school educators are expected to manage a single set of students throughout the day. They offer a broad understanding of concepts.

Elementary school educators should:

Teach almost all subjects to a group of students.
Emphasize building basic skills.
Get creative by using interactive methods or engaging activities.

Middle school educators are expected to cater to diverse sets of students with knowledge of various specialised subjects.

Middle school educators should:

Have a great understanding of a specific subject.
Use presentations, projects, or discussions to teach.
Handle diverse learning needs.

Also Read: Second Major – Choosing the Right School for Double Majors and Dual Degrees.

Classroom Environment and Student Behavior

Elementary school teachers are expected to manage a set of students, which creates a sense of community and comfort.

Elementary school educators should:

Set the classroom rules.
Act as a role model for the young ones.
Set the behavioral tone.

Middle school teachers are expected to transition from one class to another daily and manage different groups seamlessly.

Middle school educators should:

Possess classroom management skills.
Manage bullying, attitude problems, and fighting.
Allow independence with responsibility.

Career Growth and Certification Paths

Elementary school teachers will start with a broad teaching licence (K-6) and manage a wide range of subjects.

Career growth of an Elementary school educator:

Starts with an Elementary license.
Covers a broad curriculum.
Advance career as Administrator or Curriculum Specialist.

Middle school teachers typically begin with a subject-specific license (for Grades 6-8) that provides an in-depth understanding of the subject.

Career growth of a Middle school educator:

Starts with a deep understanding of the subject chosen.
Can involve an additional course on a relevant subject.
Can advance career as Department Head or Curriculum Coordinator.

Personality Fit and Teaching Philosophy

Elementary school educators are expected to be nurturing and caring, as they often deal with young students who require a great deal of support.

Elementary school educators should:

Repeat instructions or lessons.
Be able to explore topics in a creative way.
Be good at Child development psychology.

Middle school educators are supposed to be understanding towards the challenges that pre-teens and teens face.

Middle school educators should:

Encourage participation and allow students to express themselves.
Be passionate about the chosen subject.
Help students develop teamwork skills.

Also read: Doctor of Education (Ed.D) Vs PhD in Education: Which one is right for K-12 Leaders?

Benefits and Drawbacks of Each Teaching Level

Both Elementary and Middle schools have their own set of benefits and challenges. One deals with young kids, the other deals with tweens. Let’s discuss the pros and cons.

Benefits of Elementary School Teaching

Creative teaching.
Strong bonding with students.
Developmental skills.

Drawbacks of Elementary School Teaching

Time-consuming.
Demanding parents in some cases.
Expertise in all subjects.

Benefits of Middle School Teaching

Focus on one subject.
Independent students.
Development of critical thinking skills.

Drawbacks of Middle School Teaching

Challenges with behavior.
Emotionally draining.
Need adaptability to meet academic requirements.

Also Read: Is an Accelerated Online Degree Right for You? Pros, Cons, and Career Paths

Programs at Edgewood University that Prepare You for Both Pathways

Edgewood University offers numerous Education programs in online, hybrid, or on-campus modes. Let’s have a look at some of the programs.

🎓 Explore Our Top-Rated Courses at Edgewood

Take the next step in your career with industry-relevant online courses designed for working professionals.

View All Courses

FAQs on Choosing Between Elementary and Middle School Teaching

Q: What is the most significant difference between teaching Elementary and Middle school?
Ans: Elementary school is designed for young minds in the 5- to 11-year-old age group. Middle school is for pupils aged 11 years or older.

Q: Which is more challenging, elementary or middle school teaching?
Ans: There is no clear answer to this question as both have pros and cons. Elementary school requires you to provide a learning and nurturing environment and teach foundation-level skills. Middle school demands tackling puberty, teen behavior, and academic challenges.

Q: Can I switch from teaching elementary to middle school later?
Ans: Yes, it is possible to switch from teaching Elementary to Middle school if you have the required credentials, such as those in multiple subjects or professional experience.

Q: Do I need a different license for middle school vs elementary school?
Ans: Yes, there are different licenses for Elementary school and Middle school. An Elementary school teacher is taught to cover a broad range of subjects. A Middle school teacher has a specialization in a specific topic.

Q: Does Edgewood University offer programs for both teaching levels?
Ans: Yes, Edgewood University offers programs for both teaching levels. It provides programs for K-9 (Elementary school), Secondary schools, and students with special needs.